First Choice Insurance Carriers 215-710-8885
Before calling in a claim make sure you have your policy number. The rep will need it to open the claim.
First Choice Insurance
Aegis
Customer service & Claims (800) 233-2160
American Modern
Customer Service & Claims (800) 543-2644
ASI (Progressive Homeowners)
Customer Service & Claims (866) 274-8765
Bristol West
Customer Service & Claims (800) 274-7865
Donegal
Customer service & Claims (800) 321-1117
Billing (800) 321-1117 opt 5
First Choice Insurance
Foremost
Billing (800) 532-4221
Claims (800) 527-3907
Foremost Signature
Billing (800) 255-0332
Claims (800) 854-6011
Gainsco
Customer Service (866) 424-6726
Claims (800) 699-1561
Geico
Customer Service
(800) 207-7847
Claims (866) 509-9444
First Choice Insurance
Goodville
Customer Service & Claims (800) 448-4622
Billing & Claims (800) 854-4695
Glass Claims after hours (877) 445-5780
Grange
Customer Service & Claims (800) 422-0550
Billing Extension. 2369
Grinnell
Customer Service & Billing (800) 362-2041 Ext. 2455
Claims (877) 467-2252
Guard
Customer & Billing (800) 673-2465
Claims (888) 639-2567
First Choice Insurance
Hagerty
Customer Service& Billing (800) 747-5348
Claims (800) 385-0274 or claims@hagerty.com
Hanover
Customer Service & Claims (800) 922-8427
Hanover Fire & Casualty
Customer Service & Claims (800) 919-3473
Hartford
Customer Service & Billing (800) 771-8557
Claims (800) 243-5860
Liberty Mutual
Claims (844) 325-2467
First Choice Insurance
National General
Customer Service, Claims & Billing (888) 325-1190
Nationwide
Claims (800) 421-3535
Billing (800) 282-1446
Next
Claims (855) 222-5919
Openly
Customer Service (857) 990-9080 Ext 1 or 0
Billing (857) 990-9080 Ext. 2
Claims (888) 808-4842
Progressive
Customer Service, Claims & Billing (877) 776-2436
First Choice Insurance
Safeco
Customer Service & Claims (800) 332-3226
Glass Claims (800) 862-6777
Steadily
Customer Service, Claims & Billing (888) 000-0000
Travelers
Customer Service
(877) 878-2468
Billing (800) 842-8574
Claims (800) 252-4633
Contact us
Office: 215-710-8885
Contact Us: info@fcibroker.com
Mailing Address:
1818 Bethlehem Pike
Box 45
Flourtown PA 19031